Porsche 911 vs 718: Which One to Drive in Italy
The 911 is the rear-engine grand tourer with a back seat you can use in a pinch. The 718 is the mid-engine, two-seat specialist built around balance and steering feel. Both are unmistakably Porsche, and on Italian roads they feel very different. If you are choosing one for a week on the Amalfi Coast, a weekend in the Dolomites or a wedding in Tuscany, the right answer depends less on the spec sheet than on how you plan to spend the days.
This guide compares the two on what matters behind the wheel: layout, speed, space, comfort and cost. It then turns the comparison into a practical choice for a rental trip in Italy.
TL;DR
The 718 (Cayman coupe, Boxster convertible) is a mid-engine two-seater: sharper, more agile and more focused on the driver.
The 911 is rear-engine, wider and more refined, and many versions add two small rear seats and a broader range of body styles.
In Italy a 911 Carrera starts at €142,855, so the 718 is not always the cheaper car once you reach the top versions.
For long transfers, mixed luggage and a more relaxed pace, choose the 911. For twisting mountain roads and a pure driving day, choose the 718.
When you rent, the best car is the one that suits the itinerary, so decide the route first and the badge second.
Table of Contents
The core difference: where the engine sits
Everything else follows from one decision. In the 718 the engine sits behind the seats and ahead of the rear axle. Porsche describes the mid-engine concept of the 718 range as a way to deliver dynamic cornering, drawing on the spirit of its mid-engined race cars. In the 911 the engine hangs behind the rear axle, a layout that has defined the car for decades.
The practical result, as one Porsche retailer summarizes it, is that the 718 is a two-seater while the applicable 911 Carrera models are 2+2s, and the 911 offers a wider spread of body styles and performance configurations.
In plain terms:
718: the car rotates willingly, turns in crisply and feels light on its feet. It rewards a driver who enjoys working a road.
911: the car feels planted and secure, with a stronger sense of traction when you accelerate out of a corner. It rewards a driver who wants to cover ground quickly and calmly.
Models you will actually meet
The 718 family is simple: the Cayman is the fixed-roof coupe and the Boxster is the open-top roadster. Both are two-seaters. At the top of the range sit the track-minded GT4 RS and Spyder RS.
The 911 family is broader. The Carrera is the core coupe, the Carrera 4 adds all-wheel drive, the GTS versions sharpen the character, and the Turbo S sits at the extreme end. Cabriolet and Targa body styles add open-air options.
That range matters for a rental. A buyer picks one 911 and keeps it for years. A renter can match a version to the trip, so an open-top car for a coastal week and a coupe with all-wheel drive for an alpine one. The 911 gives you more ways to do this. The 718 gives you a more concentrated idea of what a Porsche sports car should be.
Performance: numbers and what they feel like
The Porsche Italia comparison tool gives a clear picture. The 718 Cayman GT4 RS and Spyder RS reach 100 km/h in 3.4 seconds. The 911 Carrera does it in 3.9 seconds with the Sport Chrono package, and the 911 Turbo S in 2.5 seconds. On power, the same source lists 290 kW (394 hp) for the Carrera and 368 kW (500 hp) for the Cayman GT4 RS.
Two things stand out.
The 718 is not simply the slower car. The range-topping 718s out-accelerate a standard Carrera, and they do it with a lighter, more agile body.
The fastest 911s sit in another league. A Turbo S is a different kind of car altogether, built for effortless, enormous pace.
On Italian roads, outright acceleration is rarely the limiting factor. Speed limits, traffic, tunnels and village centers mean you use a small part of any of these cars’ potential. What you notice is how the car responds to small inputs, how it settles over a rough surface and how tiring it is after four hours.
Handling and driving character
Drivers who have tried both tend to describe the same split. In a comparison by Autoweek, the 718 GTS was praised for a balance that felt perfect, while the 911 Carrera T was felt to have far superior grip. That sums up the trade: the 718 feels more communicative at the limit, the 911 gives you more confidence to lean on the car.
Porsche’s own description of the 718 Cayman GT targets sports-car enthusiasts who value unfiltered driving, agility and a close connection to the engine, while keeping everyday versatility. A UK retailer’s comparison frames the 911 as the grand tourer and the 718 as the more focused driver’s machine, and notes that the 911 offers more advanced technology and luxury options, including an 855-watt Burmester audio system.
For a weekend enthusiast who plans to take the Stelvio, the Futa Pass or the roads around Lake Como, that focus is the appeal of the 718. For someone who wants the same drive plus a car that feels at ease on the autostrada, the 911 is the safer bet.
Space, seats and luggage
This is where the two diverge most in daily use, and where rental trips succeed or fail.
Seats. Porsche itself notes that the 718 Cayman and Boxster are two-seaters, while many 911 models have two smaller rear seats. Those seats are not for adults on a long drive, but they take a jacket, a camera bag or a child for a short hop. Porsche also says both cars can work as daily drivers if their passenger and luggage space fits your needs.
Luggage. The 718 has two luggage compartments, one at the front and one at the rear, according to Porsche Italia’s 718 catalog. That split helps with soft bags, though the openings are not generous. The 911’s luggage space sits mostly at the front, and combined with the rear seats it gives you somewhere to put an extra bag in the cabin.
Size. The 911 is longer, wider and heavier than the 718, which you feel on narrow historic streets. Parking in a medieval center, a ZTL-adjacent garage or a coastal village is easier in the 718. Those few centimeters count in Positano or Portofino.
A useful rule: two people with two soft bags each can travel in either car. Add a third piece of luggage, a golf bag or a stroller, and the 911 with its rear seats becomes the sensible choice.
Price in Italy
On the new-car market, the 911 Carrera starts at €142,855 in Italy and the Carrera 4 GTS at €192,711. The 2025 718 Cayman GT4 RS and 718 Spyder RS both start at €165,590.
The comparison is more subtle than it looks.
The entry 718 versions sit well below the entry 911. That is the reason many shoppers see the 718 as the cheaper way into the brand.
At the top of the 718 range, the price overtakes a base Carrera, because you are paying for track-derived hardware.
The 911 climbs steeply with GTS and Turbo versions.
For a renter none of this means owning the car. What it tells you is how each car is positioned: the 718 as the focused entry to the brand and a track-capable halo at the top, the 911 as the broad, refined center of the range.
Technology and comfort
The 911 tends to carry more of Porsche’s technology. The 911 Carrera 4 GTS features Porsche Digital Interaction with customizable widgets, an App Centre that includes Apple Music, and Porsche Connect with music and video streaming, Voice Pilot and remote services through the My Porsche app. On a long Italian drive, this means better navigation and easier media, though most renters will simply connect a phone.
The 718 is more stripped back in feel, which is part of its charm. Less cabin to insulate means more mechanical sound and more road feedback. If you value quiet on a four-hour run from Milan to Florence, the 911 is the more restful car.
911 vs 718 at a glance
Criterion | Porsche 911 | Porsche 718 (Cayman / Boxster) |
Engine position | Rear | Mid |
Seating | 2+2 on many models | Two seats |
Body styles | Coupe, Cabriolet, Targa | Coupe (Cayman), roadster (Boxster) |
Character | Grand tourer, planted, refined | Agile, balanced, driver-focused |
Luggage | Front space plus rear seats | Front and rear compartments |
Size | Longer, wider | Smaller, easier in tight towns |
Entry price in Italy (new) | Lower at entry; €165,590 for GT4 RS and Spyder RS | |
Best for | Long trips, mixed luggage, comfort | Mountain roads, short stays, pure driving |
Which one suits which trip in Italy
Let the itinerary decide.
Choose the 911 if:
you are covering long distances between regions, such as Milan to Rome or Venice to Florence;
you carry more than two soft bags, or you may need to seat a third person briefly;
you want an open or targa roof for coastal driving, or all-wheel drive for alpine weather;
the car is for a business arrival, an event or a wedding, where presence and comfort matter.
The 911 Carrera T, a lighter and more driver-oriented 911 version, shows how the line can lean toward purity. You can see one detailed in this Porsche 911 Carrera T showcase and judge how the 911 can be set up for a keener drive.
Choose the 718 if:
the heart of the trip is a road: passes, lakes, hairpins and hill towns;
you travel as a couple with light luggage;
you plan to park in small villages and narrow streets;
you want the most direct steering and balance Porsche offers at the price.
If your list is mostly the coast, our guide to Porsche rental on the Amalfi Coast goes deeper on which model and roof style work on those narrow cliffside roads.
Practical points before you rent in Italy
Driving licence and age. Requirements for high-performance cars are set by the rental company and its insurer. Confirm them when you ask for a quote, before you fix travel plans.
Deposit and insurance. Exotic and sports cars carry larger deposits and specific excess terms. Ask for them in writing.
Limited traffic zones. Many Italian historic centers restrict entry to cars without a permit, and cameras issue fines automatically. Ask your hotel how to register your plate if you plan to drive into a center.
Mileage. A mountain-pass itinerary uses a lot of kilometers. Check the daily allowance.
Luggage test. Send the dimensions of your bags before booking so the car can be matched to them.
Tires and weather. An alpine trip outside summer calls for a conversation about tires and all-wheel drive.
Perspective: how we would choose
We hear the same question every season, and the honest answer is that most guests ask for the car they have seen in photographs, then change their mind when we walk through the itinerary. The 911 wins more bookings for trips that include an airport arrival, a hotel with limited parking and three or four destinations. The 718 wins when the guest tells us they care mostly about the drive itself.
Our approach is to ask about the route, the luggage and the people before we suggest a model. We also guarantee the exact model you booked, because nothing spoils a trip like arriving to find a substitute. If you are comparing the 911 with other sports and grand-touring cars, our pieces on the 911 against a Mercedes-AMG GT and the 911 against an Audi R8 show how we think through those choices, and our Ferrari versus Porsche comparison does the same for the question one step up.
— andrea
Renting a Porsche with us
If you have settled on a Porsche, you can see what is available on our Rent a Porsche in Italy page. We offer delivery to the location you choose, flexible rental periods and personal recommendations on the right model for your route. Tell us your dates, your destinations and your luggage, and we will propose the car that fits. Prices are not published for these models, so ask us for a quote for your dates.
For wider options, including other brands, browse our luxury car rental in Italy range.
FAQ
Is the Porsche 718 faster than the 911?
Not always. The 718 Cayman GT4 RS and Spyder RS reach 100 km/h in 3.4 seconds, against 3.9 seconds for a 911 Carrera with Sport Chrono. The 911 Turbo S, however, does it in 2.5 seconds. It depends on which versions you compare.
Is the 718 or the 911 more expensive?
The entry-level 718 costs less than the entry 911, but the gap closes at the top. In Italy the 911 Carrera starts at €142,855, and the 718 Cayman GT4 RS starts at €165,590.
Is a 911 better than a Cayman?
It is better for different things. The 911 offers more range, 2+2 seating and a more refined cabin, so it suits long trips. The Cayman is smaller, more agile and more focused, so it suits keen drivers and tight roads.
Which is better for a trip in Italy?
Pick the 911 for long transfers and more luggage, and the 718 for mountain roads and short stays. If you are unsure, tell us your route and we will recommend a model.
Sources
Recommended
Comments